Skip to Main Content

Systematic review

A step by step guide to doing a systematic review or other forms of Evidence Synthesis

Structuring the search strategy

Thanks to your preliminary searches you should have a rough idea of what literature is out there to find and how the topic is defined and described in titles and abstracts. Going back to your question framework will show the main concepts to search for and provide an overall structure for your search strategy. You will then need to decide and how to translate those concepts into a searchable format.

Building your search from question framework concepts

Your search strategy will be based on the key concepts from your PICO, PCC or other framework. However, a good search does not always require inclusion of all concepts, in fact your search should include as few concepts as possible to reduce bias and maximise sensitivity.
 

Consider excluding some concepts from your search

Including outcomes in your search strategy can sometimes make it harder to find relevant evidence. This is because:

  • You may not know all possible outcomes in advance.
  • Outcomes can be described in many different ways in the literature and databases.
  • Trying to include all potential outcomes (positive, negative, or no effect) can make your search overly long and complex.
  • Missing even one key term may unintentionally exclude relevant results, introducing bias.

For this reason, it is often better to leave outcomes out of your search strategy—especially unless you are focusing on one or two clearly defined outcomes. The same principle applies to concepts that are unclear or exploratory, such as risk factors, barriers, or facilitators. Including these can limit your results if they are not consistently described or indexed.

In a 2024 paper, Farhad Shokraneh acknowledges the challenges of “search-resistant concepts” and suggests practical approaches for handling these concepts in research, such as excluding them from the search strategy. The paper also explains when and how each approach should be applied. Shokraneh F. Stop searching and you will find it: Search-Resistant Concepts in systematic review searches. BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine Published Online First: 06 August 2024. doi: 10.1136/bmjebm-2023-112798
 

Splitting concepts

For some questions you may find you have to divide one concept into two smaller ones to search for it effectively. For instance if your Population was male thyroid cancer patients you would need to search men as a concept (using relevant keywords and subject headings), thyroid cancer as another concept and then combine them with AND to create the male thryoid cancer population concept.
 

A one concept search

For some topics, for instance for a new surgical technique, technology, drug, very rare disease or other such niche subject, one concept of the question framework (such as solely intervention or population) may be enough to find all available literature, as the number of results to find is small enough that focusing it further by adding other concepts would have no utility.
For wider or well researched topics (e.g Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus) you will always need to have several concepts in the strategy to keep the number of results manageable and the relevancy high.

Last Updated: Nov 17, 2026 11:58 AM