This page describes the most common types of review done at Imperial and presents a table comparing aims and features of Narrative, Systematic, Scoping, Rapid and Umbrella reviews.
For a broad overview, background context or selective expert summary of a topic when more rigorous and systematic review methods are not permitted or required.
The traditional narrative literature review describes the amount and nature of evidence on a topic without formal appraisal or synthesis. Accuracy and reproducibility are not the focus of literature reviews and so the author has more leeway to introduce their own understanding and so the selection of literature and conclusions drawn are at risk of bias. The synthesis and summary is often in words (narrative) rather than employing statistical methods. While it is helpful to still search systematically for efficiency, the strategy does not have to aim for comprehensiveness in evidence gathering.
For narrowly focused questions requiring high-quality, reproducible evidence.
Systematic reviews "can provide syntheses of the state of knowledge in a field, addressing questions that otherwise could not be answered by individual studies. They aim to discover and be inclusive of, all relevant studies to find all the data available to answer the research question. They attempt to minimise bias using explicit, systematic methods that are planned and documented in advance with a protocol. They are transparently reported, including publishing search strategies, so that the results can be verified or reproduced, using a suitable reporting guideline (such as PRISMA 2020). A meta analysis may be conducted if data is homogenous.
For mapping evidence, identifying research gaps, exploring emerging or complex topics.
While a systematic review such as an effectiveness or interventional review looks for a specific answer in a narrow topic e.g. "is this treatment more effective than that treatment on this population with this disease?" a scoping review looks at multiple answers or a wider viewpoint e.g. "what are the barriers and facilitators for these people doing this activity in this setting?" This review type will not affect your information searching too much as you will still be aiming to have a fully comprehensive search strategy but may affect how you analyse or describe the results. Like a systematic review, scoping reviews should be conducted and reported systematically and transparently.
For timely evidence gathering for actionable insights in a shorter timeframe.
These are similar to systematic reviews, but designed to be completed in a shorter time (often a few weeks to months) and are used when evidence is required in a more timely and resource efficient manner. Reviews should not aim to be less systematic than a standard systematic review, so as to avoid bias, but the review can be done in less time by narrowing the scope of the question, limiting the search e.g. by study design or year, only using single researchers at certain stages of the screening, data extraction and risk of bias assessment (with the second reviewer just checking a certain percentage) and writing up a descriptive or narrative summary rather than doing a meta-analysis.
For consolidating high-level evidence to provide a comprehensive "birds eye view" of a research topic.
Umbrella reviews are like a systematic review but includes only other systematic reviews as evidence. If a number of similar scoping or systematic reviews have been done on a topic it can be useful to do an umbrella review to assess all the higher levels of evidence on a broad but well-defined research topic. They are used to evaluate treatment effects of interventions across multiple diseases, assess epidemiological associations between risk factors and health outcomes and inform clinical guidelines and policy decisions by providing a comprehensive summary of evidence.
Narrativeliterature review | Systematic review | Scoping Review | Rapid Review | Umbrella Review | |
Time and resources | Low, can be relatively quick to complete | High, can take 6-18 months | Moderate to High, 3-18 months | Low to Moderate, typically a few weeks to 5 months | Moderate to High, 2-8 months |
Aim/output | To provide a broad, descriptive summary of existing literature on a topic, often to contextualise an issue or support an argument. Output is a narrative summary, not a formal synthesis. | To answer a narrow, pre-defined research question by identifying, appraising and synthesising all available evidence. Output is a comprehensive, reproducible synthesis (with meta-analysis where data allow) to inform practice, policy or clinical decisions. | To map the breadth and nature of evidence on a topic, clarify key concepts and identify gaps in the literature. Output is a descriptive overview/map of the evidence base, often used to determine feasibility of a future systematic review. | To answer a focused question using systematic review methods, but with abbreviated or streamlined steps to produce evidence quickly for time-sensitive decisions (e.g. emerging health threats, urgent policy questions). | To summarise findings across multiple existing systematic reviews/meta-analyses on related questions. Output is a high-level synthesis of the review-level evidence, useful for comparing interventions or getting a broad picture quickly. |
Best suited for | Introductions, background sections, or informing readers broadly on a subject where methodological rigour is not the primary goal. | Questions needing definitive, high-certainty evidence to change practice, policy or guidelines. | Exploratory questions, emerging topics, or scoping the literature before committing to a full systematic review. | Situations needing robust evidence under real time or resource constraints. | Comparing multiple interventions/outcomes, or getting a rapid, broad overview when several systematic reviews already exist on the topic. |
Research question | Broad or narrow topic e.g. What are the main causes of burnout among US healthcare workers? | Narrow and focused e.g. What is the impact of anti-amyloid drugs on adults with mild cognitive impairment or mild dementia due to Alzheimer's disease? | Broad or narrow, often exploratory e.g. What QoL questionnaires are available for paediatric patients following tonsillectomies with or without adenoidectomies for chronic infections or SDB? | Similar to a systematic review, but scoped to be answerable within a compressed timeframe (weeks rather than months). | Broad, comparative e.g. What do systematic reviews tell us about the comparative effectiveness of interventions for chronic lower back pain? |
A priori protocol | Not required | Explicit, formal protocol required | Explicit, formal protocol required | Recommended but often abbreviated; may not always be registered given time constraints
| Formal protocol recommended |
Reviewers | Single or multiple reviewers | Multiple reviewers required to reduce error and bias | Multiple reviewers required to reduce error and bias | Multiple reviewers preferred, though some steps (e.g. screening) may be done by a single reviewer with partial verification to save time
| Multiple reviewers required to reduce error and bias |
Scope of literature | Selective, not exhaustive. May only use one database or search tool | Focused and exhaustive within a defined criteria. Multiple databases (and potentially grey literature sources) are used | Focused, can be exhaustive or aim for diversity. Multiple databases (and potentially grey literature sources) are used | Focused, but limited. Fewer databases and sources searched than a full systematic review to save time
| Focused and exhaustive within a defined criteria. Multiple databases (and potentially grey literature sources) are used |
Search strategy | Not formal or systematic. No specified or reported strategy | Explicit, systematic, and transparent search strategy for each database, reported in review | Explicit, systematic, and transparent search strategy for each database, reported in review | Explicit, transparent but streamlined. May limit date ranges, languages, or number of databases; still reported in review
| Explicit, systematic, and transparent search strategy for each database, reported in review |
Study selection criteria | Selection criteria is not formally defined. Studies can be "cherry picked" to support the author's argument | Strict and defined a priori. All studies that fit the inclusion criteria are selected and are reviewed at title abstract and full-text level by more than one reviewer | Strict or more flexible, defined a priori. All studies that fit the inclusion criteria are selected and are reviewed at title abstract and full-text level by more than one reviewer | Strict and defined a priori, but screening may be accelerated (e.g. single-reviewer screening)
| Strict and defined a priori. Only systematic reviews/meta-analyses meeting inclusion criteria are selected |
Quality appraisal | No formal quality assessment of evidence | Formal and systematic critical appraisal using defined criteria (e.g. Cochrane Risk of Bias assessment) | Not mandatory. Reviewers may decide to assess quality depending on the purpose of the review | Often included but abbreviated; may use a simplified checklist rather than a full formal appraisal
| Formal appraisal of included reviews' quality (e.g. AMSTAR-2) |
Data extraction | No standardised data extraction forms. Data may not be extracted | Standardised data extraction forms | Standardised data extraction forms | Standardised data extraction forms, though the set of extracted variables may be reduced
| Standardised data extraction forms |
Synthesis method | Narrative synthesis, not suitable for meta-analysis | Quantitative or qualitative. Meta-analysis if data is homogenous | Quantitative or qualitative, not suitable for meta-analysis | Narrative or quantitative synthesis, depending on time available; formal meta-analysis less common
| Narrative or quantitative synthesis comparing results across included reviews |
Reporting | No reporting guidelines mandated | Must report review methods via PRISMA guidelines (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) | Must report review methods via PRISMA-ScR guidelines (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) | Should report via PRISMA guidelines, with a note on which steps were abbreviated and why
| Should report via PRISMA guidelines, adapted for review-of-reviews reporting |
Potential for bias | High: selective, non-exhaustive searching and no formal quality appraisal. | Low: formal protocol, exhaustive multi-database search, dual reviewers and mandatory quality appraisal (see Quality Appraisal row) are designed to minimise selection, reporting and reviewer bias. | Moderate: exhaustive search and dual reviewers reduce selection bias, but because quality appraisal is not mandatory (see Quality Appraisal row), risk of bias within included studies may go unassessed. | Moderate: streamlined searching and screening trade rigour for speed, risking missed studies or reviewer errors.
| Depends on the quality of included reviews - appraisal of review quality (see Quality Appraisal row) helps flag this, but findings can inherit bias present in the underlying systematic review. |
Last Updated: Nov 17, 2026 11:58 AM
library@imperial.ac.uk
+44 (0)20 7594 8810
Content created by Imperial College London Library Services, CC BY 4.0 unless otherwise noted.